The goat. The sheep. The cow. The pig. Ten thousand years of civilisation, on four legs.
Every critique of modern livestock farming proceeds from the same unspoken assumption: that these animals are a recent industrial invention we can set aside now that we have better options. They are not. They were domesticated before the wheel, before writing, before any of the things we point to when we describe the beginning of civilisation. In several cases, they are a significant reason civilisation began at all.
This series looks at each of the major livestock animals in turn: their origin, their contribution, what we lose when we lose them, and what the case against them actually amounts to when pressed for evidence. The conclusion, in each case, is broadly the same: the animal is not the problem. The framing is the problem.
I. The Goat: First
Ten thousand years ago in the Zagros Mountains of western Iran, early humans struck a deal with a wiry, fence-testing, bramble-eating animal whose hoofprints are literally pressed into the walls of the first human settlements. The goat was first: before the sheep, before the cow, before the pig. That is not a metaphor. That is archaeology.
II. The Sheep: The Animal That Built Britain
The Cotswolds are named for the sheep pen. The Lord Chancellor still sits on the Woolsack. Cistercian monks paid Richard I’s ransom in fleece. For seven hundred years, wool was officially declared half the wealth of England. Now the sheep is being blamed for destroying the uplands it has shaped for ten thousand years. The evidence is considerably thinner than a wool bale.
III. The Cow: The Animal That Built The World
The word fee began as a cow. So did finance, peculiar, and pecuniary. The ox-drawn plough broke the heavy soils that made cities possible. Tallow lit the streets of London before electricity. Eighty founding females, domesticated in Anatolia 10,500 years ago, gave rise to every bovine on earth. The cow did not just feed civilisation. It created the conditions for civilisation to exist.
IV. The Pig: Wrongly Convicted
Two separate civilisations independently domesticated the wild boar because the logic was self-evident: the pig eats what no one else will and returns it as meat, fat, organ flesh, lard, and fertiliser. It was then banned for being inconvenient in a climate that didn’t suit it, a local inconvenience elevated into eternal religious law. Then condemned again, in the modern era, for a fatty acid profile it only developed after we started feeding it grain.
Related reading
- Why Cows Aren’t Bringing The Apocalypse
- Debunking The Many Myths Of Cattle Farming
- The Carnivores Of History: How Meat Built Empires
- Can You Eat Pork On The Carnivore Diet?
- The Farm Is Worth Three Million. The Farmer Earns Thirty-Seven Grand.
- The British Table
- How Seed Oils Poisoned The Planet
Everything in this guide
The goat, the sheep, the cow and the pig.
The other guides
Each guide collects the articles worth reading on one subject. Start wherever the problem is.
- Start Here: where to begin, in the order that makes sense.
- Carnivore Foundations: what to eat, what to avoid, and how to run the first weeks.
- Carnivore Fat Loss: how the fat comes off without counting anything.
- Carnivore And Building Muscle: protein, training, and the pairing that always worked.
- Carnivore And Health: cholesterol, gut, hormones, and the honest evidence.
- The Case Against Plants: what the vegetables were promising, and whether they deliver.
- Seed Oils: how an industrial waste product ended up in your kitchen.
- The History Of Carnivore: ice age hunters, Victorian doctors, and the modern revival.
- The British Table: dripping, offal, and what this country ate before it got sick.
- Carnivore Recipes: the cooking, with the fat ratio kept where it belongs.
Follow me on Twitter or Instagram, or find out what the coaching programme involves below.
